Old-School Cocktails You Need to Try

Cocktails, Drinks
on April 6, 2015
Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe
Show Me The Yummy

With the end of AMC’s Mad Men quickly approaching, we thought we’d take the time to recognize one of our favorite things about the show. No, it isn’t the retro-stylish outfits or Don Draper’s winning smile. What we like best about the award-winning, drama-infused tribute to the 60’s is its booze.

Back in the day, bartenders actually took the time to craft complex, potent libations. The half-hearted, watered-down rum-and-cokes you get these days simply wouldn’t fly. To prove the supremacy of the old-school cocktail, we’ve rounded up blogger recipes for some of the best drinks that (until recently) got all-but-lost to time. Bottoms up!

The Gin Rickey

Gin Rickey | Relish.com

Oh So Beautiful Paper

The Gin Rickey’s biggest claim-to-fame is its mention in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby. The drink is supposedly named after Colonel “Joe” Ricky, a DC lobbyist that was known for entertaining elected officials in cocktail lounges. The recipe? A simple-but-refreshing combo of gin, lime juice, and club soda.


Classic Tom Collins

Classic Tom Collins | Relish.com

Culinary Ginger

A Tom Collins is a gin cocktail made with lemon, soda water, and sugar. The story behind the name is a pretty good one: in the late 1800’s, there was a prank going around where Person A would approach Person B and ask, “Have you seen Tom Collins?” Person B would say no, and then Person A would tell him that Tom was going around spreading rumors about him. After getting sufficiently riled up, Person B would eventually figure out that Tom Collins didn’t actually exist.

Ok, so it’s kind of a lame joke, but who are we to judge what went viral in 1874? Anyway, one clever bartender decided to name a cocktail “Tom Collins” so that whenever a person came into the bar asking for him, they would have unwittingly ordered a drink.



Not-So-Classic-Sidecare Recipe | Relish.com

The Prudent Life

Talk about delicious—this old-timey combo of brandy, lemon juice, and triple sec is downright dangerous. Its past is murky, but it’s generally agreed that the Sidecar originated in 1920’s Paris, making it an impossibly stylish drink. We’ll take another, please!



Manhattan Cocktail Recipe | Relish.com

Honestly Yum

A good Manhattan is a benchmark by which all other cocktails can be judged. This classy, pre-Prohibition throwback combines bourbon, sweet vermouth, and bitters. Rumor has it that it was created specifically for Winston Churchill’s mother. Whether or not that’s true, the drink definitely does justice to whoever inspired it.



Negroni Cocktail Recipe | Relish.com

Go Go Go Gourmet

Not for the faint of heart, the Negroni is definitely an acquired taste. The bitter combo of gin, vermouth russo, and Campari was created at Bar Casoni in Florence when a gruff, rugged man named Count Camillo Negroni ordered it. If you’re looking to score cool-points, this drink is definitely the way to go.


Old Fashioned

Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe | Relish.com

Show Me The Yummy

Don Draper’s poison of choice has become incredibly popular for a reason. Though officially designated “the manliest cocktail ever,” we’d argue that anyone can enjoy this tasty mixture of sugar, bitters, and whiskey.



Vesper Martini Recipe | Relish.com

Jelly Toast

An original creation of writer Ian Fleming, the Vesper martini is 007’s go-to cocktail. Cool enough for a secret agent, it blends vodka, gin, and Lillet blanc. Enjoy—just please don’t pull a James Bond and order it “shaken, not stirred.”


The Jack Rose

Jack Rose Cocktail Recipe | Relish.com

Oh So Beautiful Paper

Extremely popular in the 20s and 30s, the Jack Rose cocktail blends applejack brandy, lemon or lime, and grenadine. It may eerily resemble Hawaiian Punch, but the taste will surprise you—the potent drink contains some seriously complex notes of tropical flavors and aromatic apple.


Found in: Cocktails, Drinks